If the Lord is really...
Illustration
"If the Lord is really with us, why has all this happened to us?" asked Gideon in the Hebrew Bible (Judges 6:13). When Rabbi Harold Kushner's son, Aaron was stricken with progeria (a rapid aging disease), the rabbi investigated the traditional religious answers for why bad things happen to good people. He discovered four answers which he considered unsatisfactory to solve the problem.
One answer said that God is trouncing us (we're being punished for our sins). Another answer said that God is teaching us (we're being educated by these misfortunes). A third answer said that God is testing us (we're afflicted so God can learn how strong we are). Finally, a fourth answer said that God is transferring us (through terminal illness from this bitter world to a better one). The rabbi found all four answers unsatisfying. He would not accept these alternatives. Jesus did not accept the neat solution that catastrophes implied some personal sin as the cause.
--Chinn
One answer said that God is trouncing us (we're being punished for our sins). Another answer said that God is teaching us (we're being educated by these misfortunes). A third answer said that God is testing us (we're afflicted so God can learn how strong we are). Finally, a fourth answer said that God is transferring us (through terminal illness from this bitter world to a better one). The rabbi found all four answers unsatisfying. He would not accept these alternatives. Jesus did not accept the neat solution that catastrophes implied some personal sin as the cause.
--Chinn
