One music critic, reviewing a...
Illustration
One music critic, reviewing a rendition of J. S. Bach's Christmas Oratorio, commented that he was sure Bach's oratorio would never replace Handel's Messiah as the Christmas favorite of the people. The main reason the critic cited was that the Bach oratorio is so long. It is actually a series of oratoria to be rendered through Christmas week. While that is a contributing factor, it is not the main reason the Bach Christmas Oratorio does not enjoy widespread popularity (because it can, after all, be done in parts). The oratorio simply lacks the sentimental and spectacular elements that characterize so much of the Christmas music. The theology Bach matched with the musical score he created to relate the Gospel of Christmas is not only orthodox, it is profound.
Jaroslav Pelikan has observed somewhere that until the recent renaissance in Luther studies, Bach stood out as the best interpreter of Luther's theology. With their vibrant understanding of the Christmas Gospel, both Luther and Bach realized that the heart of the Christmas Gospel is the fact that at Bethlehem God initiated the redemptive activity of our Lord Jesus Christ. However, Christmas has absolutely no meaning for us unless we are able to appropriate the Holy Christ Child to ourselves as our Savior and Lord, as our gift for eternal life, and as our Redeemer from sin, death and the devil. One of the chorales in Bach's oratorio concludes, "This weak little boy shall be our comfort and joy, come to destroy the devil and bring peace at last."
Jaroslav Pelikan has observed somewhere that until the recent renaissance in Luther studies, Bach stood out as the best interpreter of Luther's theology. With their vibrant understanding of the Christmas Gospel, both Luther and Bach realized that the heart of the Christmas Gospel is the fact that at Bethlehem God initiated the redemptive activity of our Lord Jesus Christ. However, Christmas has absolutely no meaning for us unless we are able to appropriate the Holy Christ Child to ourselves as our Savior and Lord, as our gift for eternal life, and as our Redeemer from sin, death and the devil. One of the chorales in Bach's oratorio concludes, "This weak little boy shall be our comfort and joy, come to destroy the devil and bring peace at last."
